Value For Specialty Coffee: The Impact Of The New SCA Cupping Protocol

Vietnamese Coffee Exporter
Value For Specialty Coffee

Value For Specialty Coffee : During the recent Re:co Symposium, the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) revealed the beta version of its groundbreaking Coffee Value Assessment. This innovative cupping form and protocol promise to revolutionize the way industry experts view and evaluate coffee by providing a more detailed and nuanced understanding of each coffee’s unique characteristics. Additionally, it aims to reduce the risk of bias in the assessment process, ensuring a fairer and more accurate evaluation.

With the SCA’s cupping system remaining unchanged since 2004, Value For Specialty Coffee this update represents a significant evolution in coffee quality assessment practices. It is poised to make a profound impact on the specialty coffee industry by enhancing the precision and reliability of coffee evaluations.

Discover the importance of the Coffee Value Assessment and its expected influence on the future of specialty coffee.

Introducing the SCA’s Enhanced value for specialty coffee Assessment

The Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) has unveiled its revamped Coffee Value Assessment, a culmination of a comprehensive three-year initiative aimed at refining its cupping and grading protocols. Value For Specialty Coffee This innovative tool is designed to revolutionize the way specialty coffee professionals globally evaluate coffee, utilizing the 100-point SCA scale that serves as the benchmark for quality within the industry.

Despite its central role in coffee assessment, the original SCA cupping form and protocol have remained largely unchanged since the early 2000s. In recent times, Value For Specialty Coffee these traditional methods have drawn criticism for overly focusing on the quantitative grading of green coffee, potentially overlooking the broader spectrum of coffee’s intrinsic qualities. The debate continues on the subjectivity versus objectivity of the cupping forms, highlighting a need for a more balanced approach to evaluating coffee.

Critiques have also extended to the SCA Coffee Taster’s Flavor Wheel, with concerns that its flavor descriptors may disproportionately reflect Western taste preferences, thereby excluding a wider range of global cultures and cuisines.

The new Coffee Value Assessment by the SCA addresses these concerns by offering a more nuanced, inclusive framework for coffee evaluation, promising to set a new standard in specialty coffee quality assessment.

The New Coffee Value Assessment: A Comprehensive Approach

The Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) has introduced the Coffee Value Assessment, a pioneering set of protocols and guidelines aimed at fostering greater fairness within the coffee supply chain. Following a survey of approximately 1,600 cupping experts from Latin America, the UK, and the US in October 2022, the SCA recognized the need to address the “intersubjectivity” in cupping. This concept suggests that traditional cupping results may not fully encapsulate a professional’s expertise or personal taste preferences.

To tackle this, the SCA initiated a pilot project in November 2022, setting the stage for an enhanced cupping form. This initiative led to the development of the Coffee Value Assessment protocol, designed to offer a more detailed and equitable evaluation process.

The protocol is structured around four distinct stages of assessment, allowing for a comprehensive analysis either individually or in combination:

  1. Physical: Focuses on the evaluation of green coffee by examining moisture content, appearance, and any bean damage. This stage adapts to various grading systems.Value For Specialty Coffee
  2. Extrinsic: Evaluates external factors like the coffee’s identity, certifications, and origin, contributing to its overall value.
  3. Affective: Captures the cupper’s subjective opinion of the coffee’s quality, utilizing the 100-point scale to quantify preferences.
  4. Descriptive: Concentrates on identifying flavor and aroma characteristics without assigning value judgments, enhancing understanding of the coffee’s profile.

This multi-faceted approach aims to revolutionize how coffee quality is assessed, ensuring that evaluations are both comprehensive and nuanced.

Enhancing Data Collection with the Coffee Value Assessment

The Specialty Coffee Association’s (SCA) existing cupping forms and guidelines have traditionally been limited to affective and descriptive evaluations. Value For Specialty Coffee The introduction of the Coffee Value Assessment (CVA) promises to broaden this scope significantly, enabling coffee professionals to access a richer and more diverse set of data regarding coffee characteristics.

SCA CEO Yannis Apostolopoulos elaborates on the CVA’s fundamental objectives, stating, “The CVA protocol acknowledges a truth well-recognized within the specialty coffee community—that the uniqueness of a specialty coffee cannot be distilled into a single defining trait. Furthermore, it recognizes the varied taste preferences that exist across different global regions.”

He further notes, “This innovative approach to valuing coffee not only acknowledges but also celebrates the wide array of taste preferences across different regions and markets, offering a more inclusive and comprehensive assessment method.”

Empowering Coffee Producers with the Coffee Value Assessment

The Specialty Coffee Association (SCA)’s Coffee Value Assessment, currently in beta, is stirring significant conversation among coffee professionals, notably for its potential benefits to coffee producers. Yannis Apostolopoulos, the CEO of SCA, highlights the groundbreaking shift this program introduces to the coffee industry, particularly in altering the power dynamics between producers and buyers.

This innovative assessment method is set to establish a globally accessible database of cupping data, offering coffee producers unparalleled insight into consumer preferences across various countries and regions. “This will empower producers to more effectively target markets that recognize the value of their coffee and are willing to pay premium prices,” Yannis notes. Such a project, unprecedented in scale, holds the promise of transformation with the continued support of the global coffee community.

The existing cupping protocols tend to simplify coffee quality into a singular score on the 100-point scale, a practice that has received widespread critique within the specialty coffee sector. This oversimplification risks undervaluing some producers’ coffee, as the final score—and consequently, the price—can significantly depend on the cupper’s level of experience.

Addressing this issue, the Coffee Value Assessment aims to ensure that coffee producers, especially smallholder farmers who often live below the poverty line, are fairly compensated for their product. This initiative is crucial for promoting equity in the coffee industry and securing a sustainable future for all involved.

Enhancing Quality Insights: The Impact of the Coffee Value Assessment

The Coffee Value Assessment introduces a comprehensive approach, enabling industry experts to evaluate coffee by incorporating both its physical and extrinsic qualities, as well as its affective and descriptive characteristics. Value For Specialty Coffee This multifaceted evaluation promises a deeper understanding of coffee’s overall quality.

Extrinsic factors, under this new framework, Value For Specialty Coffee are poised to significantly influence our perceptions of coffee quality. We might observe certain coffee-producing countries or regions gaining recognition as premium or “boutique” origins, attributed to higher scores from the Coffee Value Assessment.

Moreover, coffees boasting various certifications, such as organic or carbon-neutral labels, are likely to achieve higher overall scores. This evolution in scoring could reshape how we perceive and value coffee quality. Value For Specialty Coffee Although the full implications of the SCA’s Coffee Value Assessment are yet to be realized since it’s still pending formal implementation, its potential to transform coffee grading and assessment practices is unmistakable.Value For Specialty Coffee

The anticipated system aims to foster greater transparency concerning coffee quality and pricing. This should, ideally, empower producers to enhance the value of their coffee and penetrate new markets more effectively.Value For Specialty Coffee

While the practical outcomes of this innovative approach remain to be seen, the move towards a more open dialogue about coffee quality, the terminology used, and the scoring system itself is expected to propel the specialty coffee industry forward.