For decades, coffee associations have played an essential role in setting industry standards, providing education, and fostering a global community. But recent shifts in the coffee industry are prompting many to question the true value these associations bring. Let’s explore how this evolving dynamic is reshaping the future of coffee.
Traditional Role of Coffee Associations
Coffee associations like the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA), National Coffee Association (NCA), and the National Federation of Coffee Growers of Colombia have historically been seen as the backbone of the coffee industry. They have provided:
-
Internationally recognized quality standards.
-
Educational programs and certifications like Q Grader.
-
Events and exhibitions that bring the coffee community together.
-
A space for sharing knowledge and supporting professionals at every level.
SCA, founded in 1982, was created with a mission to “foster a global coffee community and support activity to make specialty coffee a thriving, equitable, and sustainable activity for the entire value chain.” The 2017 merger with SCA Europe was meant to create an international body representing coffee professionals around the world.
Growing Challenges and a Shift in Community Perceptions
Despite their broad reach, these coffee associations are facing scrutiny. Many members of the community, particularly in producing countries, feel their voices aren’t fully heard or represented.
Peter Gakuo of Agnimble highlights this frustration: “It’s a significant investment to obtain certifications like Q Grader. When changes happen without consultation, it sends a message that the community’s needs are secondary.”
The recent “CVA-Q takeover” – merging the Q Grader program into a new system without broad input – sparked widespread debate. Professionals questioned whether the new approach truly served the coffee community or simply pushed corporate interests.
Community Voices Calling for Representation
Diana Hoyos, founder of coffee brand in Colombia, observes: “Coffee associations once played a crucial role in setting standards, but now they feel out of touch with the realities faced by farmers and producers.”
Anete Dinne of Coffee Europe echoes this sentiment: “The community wants more than certifications and trade shows. They want transparency, equity, and real representation from the ground up.”
A Maturing Community Seeking Change
As the coffee sector grows and evolves, so too does the community that fuels it. Many are no longer content with old systems that seem more focused on revenue than real change.
Peter Gakuo puts it plainly: “This is a positive sign. It means the coffee industry is growing up and no longer accepting models that don’t serve its best interests.”
This shift is clear in the decisions of some roasters and cafés to stop displaying SCA certifications and logos, once seen as a badge of honor. Their decision signals a desire to rethink what truly matters: authentic relationships, fair practices, and locally driven initiatives.
Toward a More Equitable and Sustainable Model
The evolving relationship between coffee associations and the community is also an opportunity. Many experts see a chance to rebuild these systems so they better serve farmers, roasters, and everyone in the supply chain.
Diana points to the example of SENA, Colombia’s government-funded educational body that provides accessible training for farmers and young professionals. “SENA proves that coffee education can be a public good, not just a profit driver,” she says.
Grassroots efforts like the Asociación Antioqueña de Mujeres en Café in Colombia – co-founded by Diana – are also showing how the coffee community can create spaces for underrepresented voices, from women farmers to small-scale roasters.
Key Questions for the Future
The current debates around programs like the CVA-Q reveal deeper questions that the entire coffee community is wrestling with:
-
Are coffee associations truly listening to the people who grow, process, and roast coffee?
-
Do the certifications and memberships offered actually help small businesses thrive?
-
Will future decisions be guided by community input or top-down mandates?
Anete Dinne warns: “The Q and CVA serve entirely different purposes. Merging them shows a fundamental misunderstanding of what the community actually needs.”
Implications for the Coffee Industry
The move away from coffee associations – or at least from traditional models of them – has major implications. If fewer people renew memberships or certifications, it could reshape industry events, research priorities, and how “best practices” are defined.
Jim Cleaves, with over 40 years of coffee industry experience, says: “Trust is essential. Many question whether the SCA’s standards and protocols are truly the best way forward – and whether these associations still deserve to lead.”
This questioning is not a threat; it’s a sign of a maturing community that values inclusivity and fairness as much as profitability.
A Call for Locally Grounded, Inclusive Systems
Experts agree that the next step must be to center origin-based voices and create systems that don’t just serve the Global North. Peter Gakuo emphasizes: “Associations claiming to support sustainability and producer development must actually engage with producers, not just talk about them.”
For Diana, this means shifting the focus away from rigid, profit-driven frameworks and toward community-driven models that respect local needs and realities.
“Coffee is not just about protocols or scores,” she says. “It’s about people. Real inclusivity starts with listening to the community at every level.”
Conclusion: Building a Future Where Community Comes First
The coffee community is at a crossroads. Will it continue to rely on coffee associations that feel increasingly disconnected from the realities of farmers and small businesses? Or will it embrace new, more inclusive approaches that put people at the heart of coffee?
Jim Cleaves sums it up best: “If people move away from the SCA, it’s because they’re not seeing value. That’s a wake-up call for the whole industry.”
For lasting change, coffee must remain not just a product, but a community – one that celebrates diversity, collaboration, and fairness at every step of the supply chain.
What do YOU think about the role of coffee associations today?
Are they still essential for the industry’s future?
Or is it time for the community to build new, independent platforms to grow together?
🗣️ Share your thoughts in the comments! Let’s start a meaningful discussion with Helena Coffee—where authentic connection and real value come first.